We asked ChatGPT to recommend lawyers. 95% of firms were never named.
Law Firms · ·
When someone asks ChatGPT “who are the best family lawyers in Miami?”, it answers with a short list of names. We wanted to know how many law firms make those lists. So on October 1, 2026, we asked four AI engines to recommend lawyers and checked which of 262 randomly chosen firms they named.
Thirteen did. That’s 5%.
How we tested it
We started with 22,406 Google Business listings for lawyers in four metros: Toronto, New York City, Miami and the San Francisco Bay Area. From the firms with their own website, we drew a random sample of 80 per city. 262 of those sites could be analysed; the rest blocked our crawler, redirected elsewhere or had almost no text.
Then we asked ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google’s AI Overviews the same question for ten practice areas, from family and criminal law to immigration, tax and personal injury: “Who are the best [practice] lawyers in [city]?” Each question ran three times. We collected 479 answers.
A firm counted as named if its name or website appeared in an answer, or its site was cited, in at least one of the three runs. That’s a generous bar.
What we found
Most firms never came up. 13 of 262 firms (5%; 95% confidence interval 3 to 8%) were named by any engine. ChatGPT named 9 (3%). Gemini, Perplexity and Google’s AI Overviews named 2 to 4 each.
The city made less difference than you’d think. Toronto came out highest at 8%, then New York at 7%, the Bay Area at 3% and Miami at 2%. With samples this size, those gaps are too small to call real differences. In every city, the large majority of firms were missing.
The answers keep changing. One firm ChatGPT named came up 11 times across our questions. Only twice did it appear in all three runs of the same question; four times it appeared in just one run of three. Being named once is no promise you’ll be named the next time someone asks.
Google often shows no AI answer at all. In 48% of our Google runs (57 of 119), no AI Overview appeared. For many legal searches, the classic results are still what people see first.
“Best” and “expert” didn’t clearly help. 35% of the firm websites (93 of 262) describe themselves with unsourced terms like “best”, “top”, “leading” or “expert”, and 24% use “best” or “expert” specifically. Firms using those words were named 8% of the time, against 4% for firms that didn’t. That gap isn’t statistically significant (p = 0.23): the data can’t tell whether the words help, make no difference or hurt.
What this means if you run or market a firm
This isn’t a story about firms failing. Each of these cities has well over a thousand firms, and each AI answer names a handful. Most firms will be missing from most answers, whatever they do.
What changes is who’s in the handful. When a client does start with a chatbot, an answer that names three firms is a shortlist your firm is either on or not. Because the answers shift from one run to the next, being named sometimes counts for more than being named once.
What we’d do first (our advice, not a study finding)
Our study didn’t test what gets a firm named, so treat this as practice, not proof. It’s what we check first when a law firm asks us.
- Ask the engines yourself. Put your own practice and city into ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity, three times each. Note who comes up and which websites the answers cite. That’s your real competition in AI search, and it costs nothing.
- Make your details match everywhere. Your firm name, address, phone number and practice areas should read the same on your website, your Google Business Profile and every directory you’re listed in. AI engines piece a firm together from many sources, and conflicting details make that harder.
- Say plainly what you do and where. A page per core practice area, naming the city, the kinds of matters you take, and who handles them, with each lawyer’s bar admissions. Plain facts are easier for an engine to quote than a slogan. More on this in getting found when search answers the question itself.
- Back up claims or drop them. If you call yourself “best” or a “specialist”, name the source: the ranking, the award, the certification. Unsourced superlatives didn’t clearly help in our data, and bar advertising rules in many places restrict them. Our guide to attorney advertising rules covers the main ones; check your own jurisdiction’s.
- Check again every quarter. The answers move. A quick quarterly check tells you whether anything you changed reached the engines.
The full study
The full report, with the method, confidence intervals, limitations and charts, is free to read and reuse under CC BY 4.0: Law Firm Website & AI Visibility Index, Q4 2026.
A disclosure, as in the report: Innovara Studios builds websites and search for law firms. No firm is named in the study, and no firm paid for or previewed it.
Want to know whether AI engines name your firm? We’ll check for you: get a free AI snapshot.
Want more of our writing in your Google results? Add Innovara as a preferred source.